As we evaluate the top half of the New York Yankees’ batting order, it’s evident that stars like Aaron Judge and Juan Soto dominate, potentially carrying the offense on their own. However, the lower half of the lineup has been underperforming, presenting General Manager Brian Cashman with significant challenges as the trade deadline in late July approaches.
The Yankees are Elite at the Top of the Batting Order
Currently, Judge is delivering impressive stats with a .300/.423/.686 batting line, including 28 homers and 70 RBIs, keeping the offensive unit competitive. Soto is also having a standout year, batting .305/.431/.563 with 18 homers and 56 RBIs. These two players are performing at an elite level, which in many sports would be sufficient, but baseball demands depth across the batting order, and the Yankees are seeing a gap.
Struggles in the Lower Order
A recent lineup against the Atlanta Braves illustrates the issue. Beyond Alex Verdugo, the Yankees fielded Gleyber Torres, DJ LeMahieu, Ben Rice, Jose Treviño, and Trent Grisham. Excluding Rice, who is hitting .294, three of the final four batters have averages of .218 or lower. Despite Torres’s potential, evidenced by his historical output, his current season wRC+ of 85 suggests he’s performing 15% worse than the average MLB player. With Giancarlo Stanton sidelined due to a hamstring injury, there’s an urgent need for players like Torres to step up.
There’s a strong sentiment that the Yankees need a blockbuster trade to solidify their World Series ambitions. While their starting rotation is robust, the bullpen and the batting order could use enhancement. Anticipated returns from injury for players like Clarke Schmidt, Cody Poteet, Ian Hamilton, Scott Effross, and Lou Trivino are expected to bolster the team later in the season.
The return of Anthony Rizzo may not significantly boost the lineup, given his subpar performance this season. Instead, the Yankees might benefit from giving Ben Rice more opportunities and seeking an above-average third baseman. The ideal target, Ryan McMahon of the Colorado Rockies, is reportedly not on the trade block despite being in the midst of a career-best season, with a 122 wRC+ and a .280 average. His trade value is at its peak, with potential for 30 home runs this season.
Looking Toward the Trade Deadline
The situation could evolve as the trade deadline approaches, depending on the Rockies’ standings and needs. Meanwhile, the Yankees must navigate their immediate challenges without dropping too far in the standings. The acquisition of J.D. Davis is a step in the right direction, but it may not be sufficient. As the deadline nears, Cashman is expected to actively seek solutions to ensure the Yankees have a roster capable of a deep postseason run.