Hopes were not high before facing Salford at The Peninsula Stadium, and fans were even more concerned after the club confirmed the squad ahead of the tie.
While Jack Harrison returned to the starting XI after completing a second loan move from Leeds United, new signing Iliman Ndiaye was nowhere to be seen, not even as a substitute.
Everton signed the Senegalese forward on a £15million deal from Marseille earlier this summer [BBC Sport], helping to reinforce the Dominic Calvert-Lewin and Beto partnership up front.
However, Dyche’s side had to push forward without the 24-year-old in the squad despite impressing in training before even more difficult matchups against Coventry City, Preston North End and Roma.
Worries emerge as Iliman Ndiaye missing for Everton v Salford City
Thoughts amongst the fans have already turned to possible injuries for the new forward, who has provided a lot of hope for the attacking third of the Toffees’ squad.
While Calvert-Lewin hit a purple patch towards the end of last season, he was only able to notch seven Premier League goals across the campaign, with Beto only scoring five times since arriving last summer.
Of course, Neal Maupay has now returned to the side after a successful loan spell at Brentford, but fans were very keen for Dyche to add another forward to his ranks.